1 and 2 both look nice. Don't think the others match your house.
Nice PS work, btw!
I didn't comment before because of having to fill out my email and all that. Lame.
Anyhow, I like option one quite a bit, but I voted for 2 because I really like a change in the roof angle for the porch. It gives the house a bit more architectural interest....or something like that.
I voted for 2, but I also like 4.
I voted for 2! I also like 1, except that it goes all the way to the window. I KNOW I am a neurotic Nelly, but I'm thinking you don't need to make it easier for creepers more intrusive than yourself to be poking in your windows, amIright?